Resource losses to Ukrainian tourism caused by full-scale Russian aggression
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24917/20801653.374.7Keywords:
tourism, Russian-Ukrainian war, historical and cultural heritage, urbicide, ecocide, natural reserve fund, tourist infrastructureAbstract
This article examines the concepts of urbicide and ecocide as a part of the violent policy against the state of Ukraine since the beginning of the full- scale Russian- Ukrainian war and their influence on tourism. We analyse their impact on natural recreational and tourist resources, such as land, air, river networks, and biotic and landscape diversity. Special attention is paid to protected areas of regional and national importance included in Ukraine’s ‘natural reserve fund’ and to sites of international importance that are part of the World Network of Biosphere Reserves. The article provides information about recorded crimes in different regions of Ukraine concerning historical and cultural heritage. Since 24 February 2022, at least 569 cultural heritage sites have been destroyed due to the war, including 170 monuments of national and local importance, 146 valuable historical buildings and cultural heritage sites, and 58 memorial monuments and works of art. We analyse losses in hospitality infrastructure relative to their zoning category determined by proximity to active fighting. The paper highlights the most urgent issues of the post- war restoration of Ukraine’s tourism sector, particularly facility staffing issues and ethical considerations when commemorating war events. Research methods: collection, analysis and the generalisation of information from official and research media sources concerning the loss of natural, historical, cultural and infrastructural resources suffered by tourism as a result of Russia’s military aggression in Ukraine from 24 Feb 2022 to 01 July 2023. Results: summary of the losses to tourism destination resources and infrastructure in Ukraine by region and type of impact, and a proposed framework for planning the post- war recovery of different kinds of tourism in Ukraine. This article examines the concepts of urbicide and ecocide as a part of the violent policy against the state of Ukraine since the beginning of the full- scale Russian- Ukrainian war and their influence on tourism. We analyse their impact on natural recreational and tourist resources, such as land, air, river networks, and biotic and landscape diversity. Special attention is paid to protected areas of regional and national importance included in Ukraine’s ‘natural reserve fund’ and to sites of international importance that are part of the World Network of Biosphere Reserves. The article provides information about recorded crimes in different regions of Ukraine concerning historical and cultural heritage. Since 24 February 2022, at least 569 cultural heritage sites have been destroyed due to the war, including 170 monuments of national and local importance, 146 valuable historical buildings and cultural heritage sites, and 58 memorial monuments and works of art. We analyse losses in hospitality infrastructure relative to their zoning category determined by proximity to active fighting. The paper highlights the most urgent issues of the post- war restoration of Ukraine’s tourism sector, particularly facility staffing issues and ethical considerations when commemorating war events. Research methods: collection, analysis and the generalisation of information from official and research media sources concerning the loss of natural, historical, cultural and infrastructural resources suffered by tourism as a result of Russia’s military aggression in Ukraine from 24 Feb 2022 to 01 July 2023. Results: summary of the losses to tourism destination resources and infrastructure in Ukraine by region and type of impact, and a proposed framework for planning the post- war recovery of different kinds of tourism in Ukraine.
Downloads
Metrics
References
Arnaud, F. (2016). Memorial policies and restoration of Croatian tourism two decades after the war in former Yugoslavia. Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change, 14(3), 270-290. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1080/14766825.2016.1169348
Bondar O., Finin G., Shevchenko R (2022) Ekolohichni vyklyky voiennoho chasu: otsinka vplyvu na dovkillia kosmichnymy systemamy dystantsiinoho zonduvannia ta GPS-navihatsii [Environmental challenges of wartime: environmental impact assessment by Space Remote Sensing Systems and GPS navigation] Ekolohichni nauky : naukovo-praktychnyi zhurnal, 40-49. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.32846/2306-9716/2022.eco.4-43.7 (in Ukrainian).
Boyd, S., Reddy, M. V., Kulshreshtha, S., & Nica, M. (2023). Post-conflict tourism opportunity spectrum (POCTOS): a framework for destinations recovering from conflict. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 31(1), 131-148. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1080/09669582.2021.1993866
Buchko, Z. (2022). Naslidky viiskovoho urbitsydu dlia muzeinoi kulturnoi spadshchyny Ukrainy [Consequences of military urbicide for the museum cultural heritage of Ukraine], Viina ta turyzm, 94-98 (in Ukrainian).
Buchko, Z. (2022). Obiekty kulturnoi spadshchyny Ukrainy v umovakh viiskovoho urbitsydu [Objects of cultural heritage of Ukraine in the conditions of military urbicide], Mizhdystsyplinarni intehratsiini protsesy u systemi heohrafichnoi, turyzmolohichnoi ta ekolohichnoi nauky, 46-48 (in Ukrainian).
DeepStateUA. Channel of thorough analytics. (2023, June 20). Retrieved from: https://deepstatemap.live/en#6/49.438/32.053
Deviat raket nakryly Zaporizhzhia: znyshchyly hotel, pid ruinamy liudy. (2022, September 22). [Nine rockets hit Zaporozhye: the hotel was destroyed, people were under the ruins]. REALIST.ONLINE. Retrieved from: https://realist.online/ukr/news/devjat-raket-nakrili-zaporizhzhja-znishchili-hotel-pid-rujinami-ljudi-video (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Do 98% budivel Mariupolia zruinovani – Zelenskyi. (2022, April 21). [Up to 98% of buildings in Mariupol have been destroyed - Zelenskyi]. Ukrinform. Retrieved from: https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-ato/3463354-do-98-budivel-mariupola-vze-zrujnovani-zelenskij.html (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Evan S. Grimes, Marissa L. Kneer, Jacob F. Berkowitz Military activity and wetland-dependent wildlife: A warfare ecology perspective. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management First Published: 21 March 2023, 1-9. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1002/ieam.4767
Fedorkova, T., Bohdan, R. (2022, August 13). «Paniky ne bulo, tilky zlist»: u Nemyshlianskomu raioni Kharkova raketnym udarom RF 13 serpnia poshkodzheno hotel. ["There was no panic, only anger": in the Nemyshlyan district of Kharkiv, a Russian missile strike on August 13 damaged a hotel.]. Suspilne Novyny. Retrieved from: https://suspilne.media/270786-paniki-ne-bulo-tilki-zlist-u-nemislanskomu-rajoni-harkova-raketnim-udarom-rf-13-serpna-poskodzeno-gotel/ (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Hollier, R. (1991). Conflict in the Gulf: Response of the tourism industry. Tourism Management, 12(1), 2-4. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1016/0261-5177(91)90022-L
Honcharova, K. (2022, July 27). More v okupatsii. Yaki kurorty Ukrainy zakhopyla Rosiia pid chas viiny. [The sea is under occupation. Which resorts of Ukraine were captured by Russia during the war]. RBK-Ukraina. Retrieved from: https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/travel/more-okkupatsii-kakie-kurorty-ukrainy-zahvatila-1658919381.html (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Hlushchenko, O. (2022, March 12). Russian invaders bomb the Ukraine Hotel in the centre of Chernihiv. Ukrainska Pravda. Retrieved from: https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2022/03/12/7330583/ (accessed 1.07.2023).
Hryshyna, D. (2023, January 4). Ulamok rakety «vyrvav» piat poverkhiv u kyivskomu hoteli. Fotoreportazh. [A fragment of the rocket "tore up" five floors of a Kyiv hotel. Photo report.]. Vechirnii Kyiv. Retrieved from: https://vechirniy.kyiv.ua/news/76764/ (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Klosova, S. (2022, July 31). Mykolaivski budivli. Shcho zruinuvaly rosiiski viiska z pochatku vtorhnennia v Ukrainu. [Mykolaiv buildings. What Russian troops have destroyed since the beginning of the invasion of Ukraine]. Suspilne Novyny. Retrieved from: https://suspilne.media/266116-mikolaivski-budivli-so-zrujnuvali-rosijski-vijska-z-pocatku-vtorgnenna-v-ukrainu/ (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Kozlova, A., Piestova, I., Patrusheva, L., Lubsky, M., Nikulina, A., & Svideniuk, M. (2019). Estimation of the seasonal leaf area index in urban oak forests using Sentinel-2 time series data. European Association of Geoscientists & Engineers, 1-5. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.3997/2214-4609.201902134
Kozlova, A., Stankevich, S., Svideniuk, M., & Andreiev, A. (2021). Quantitative Assessment of Forest Disturbance with C-Band SAR Data for Decision Making Support in Forest Management. Lecture Notes in Computational Intelligence and Decision Making, 548–562. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-82014-5_37
Kozova, L. (2022, August 18). V Odeskii OVA nazvaly tsil okupantiv u Zatotsi. [The Odesa Regional Military Administration named the goal of the invaders in Zatoka]. UNIAN. Retrieved from: https://www.unian.ua/war/obstril-zatoki-v-odeskiy-ova-nazvali-cil-rosiyan-novini-odesi-11945388.html?_gl=1*1r8bxzv*_ga*MTE0ODM1NjcxOC4xNjYwOTUyNTM2*_ga_JLSK4Y8K67*MTY2MDk1MjUzNi4xLjEuMTY2MDk1MjY1MS4xOS4wLjA.*_ga_DENC12J6P3*MTY2MDk1MjUzNi4xLjEuMTY2MDk1MjY1MS4xOS4wLjA (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Kucherenko B. Yak viina vplyvaie na pryrodu Ukrajiny ta chomu zberezhennia y vidnovlennia pryrodnykh ekosystem ye vazhlyvym u povoiennomu vidnovlenni Retrieved from: https://ecoaction.org.ua/iak-vijna-vplyvaie-na-pryrodu.html (accessed 02.05.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Kunytskyi, O. (2022). Evakuatsiia kultury: chy mozhna bulo vriatuvaty vtracheni obiekty [Evacuation of culture: could the lost objects be saved]. URL: https://www.dw.com/uk/evakuacia-kulturnih-cinnostej-do-i-pid-cas-vijni-ci-mozna-bulo-vratuvati-vtracene/a-64658810?maca=ukr-rss-ukrnet-ukr-all-3816-xml (accessed 28.06.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Kryminalnyi kodeks Ukrainy [Criminal codex of Ukraine]. Retrieved from: (accessed 29.06.2023) https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2341-14#Text (in Ukrainian).
Liubitseva, O., Kochetkova, I. (2022). Kryzovyi menedzhment u pisliavoiennomu turyzmi [Crisis management in post-war tourism], Viina ta turyzm, 247-250 (in Ukrainian).
Lutsenko, Ye. (2022, October 29). Okupanty obstrilialy Nikopol: poshkodzheno zhytlovi budynky y hotel, ye poranenyi. [The occupiers shelled Nikopol: residential buildings and a hotel were damaged, and one person was injured]. Hromadske Telebachennia. Retrieved from: https://hromadske.ua/posts/okupanti-obstrilyali-nikopol-poshkodzheno-zhitlovi-budinki-j-gotel-ye-poranenij (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Malchykova, D., Pylypenko, I. (2022). Okupatsiinyi urbitsyd: miskyi dosvid i povsiakdenni praktyky naselennia (pryklad Khersona, Ukraina) [Occupation urbicide: urban experience and everyday practices of the population (the example of Kherson, Ukraine)], Ekonomichna ta sotsialna heohrafiia, 88, 6-15 (in Ukrainian).
Mansfeld, Y. (1999). Cycles of war, terror, and peace: Determinants and management of crisis and recovery of the Israeli tourism industry. Journal of Travel Research, 38(1), 30-36. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1177/004728759903800107
Mapa viiny v Ukraini - Novyny Ukrainy na karti [Map of the war in Ukraine - News of Ukraine on the map]. (2023, June 20) Retrieved from: https://liveuamap.com/uk (in Ukrainian).
Mezentsev, K., Mezentsev, O. (2022). War and the city: Lessons from urbicide in Ukraine, Czasopismo Geograficzne, 93(3), 495-521.
Mezentsev, K. (2023). «Vbyvstvo» ta «vtecha» ukrainskykh mist: viiskovyi urbitsyd i vymusheni pereselennia ["Murder" and "escape" of Ukrainian cities: military urbicide and forced resettlement], Mista ta rehiony v epitsentri prostorovykh zmin, 85 (in Ukrainian).
Natsionalna turystychna orhanizatsiia Ukrainy. (2020). Turystychnyi barometr Ukrainy 2020. [Tourist barometer of Ukraine 2020]. Retrieved from: https://nto.ua/assets/files/ntou-statistics-barometer-poster-2020.pdf (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Obstril Odesy: rosiiany «demilitaryzuvaly» hotel na uzberezhzhi. (2022, May 9). [Odesa shelling: the Russians "demilitarized" a hotel on the coast]. Ukrinform. Retrieved from: https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-ato/3478885-obstril-odesi-rosiani-demilitarizuvali-gotel-na-uzberezzi.html (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Рarkhomenko V.V., Vasyliuk O.V. (2022) Zapovidni terytorii i rosiisko-ukrainska viina. [Reserved territories and the Russian-Ukrainian War]. Suchasni fitosozolohichni doslidzhennia v Ukraini. Kyiv. Retrieved from: ttps://www.researchgate.net/publication/369537683_Zapovidni_teritorii_i_rosijsko-ukrainska_vijna (March 2022) (in Ukrainian).
Pid Berdianskom «pryletilo» po bazakh, de rozmishchuvalysia okupanty, - rairada. (2023, May 27). [Near Berdyansk «flew in» on the bases where the occupiers were located, - District Council]. RBK-Ukraina. Retrieved from: https://www.rbc.ua/rus/news/pid-berdyanskom-priletilo-bazah-de-rozmishchuvalisya-1685173756.html (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Polovyna hoteliv pislia okupatsii Kyivshchyny ne vidkrylysia, - eksperty. (2022, July 15). [Half of the hotels did not open after the occupation of Kyiv region, - experts.]. RBK-Ukraina. Retrieved from: https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/travel/polovina-zagorodnyh-oteley-okkupatsii-kievshchiny-1657873716.html (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Pryroda Ukrainy. Pryrodno-zapovidnyi fond [Nature of Ukraine. Nature reserve fund] (2023, June 20) Retrieved from: https://pzf.land.kiev.ua/ (in Ukrainian).
Ruban, Ye. V KOVA rozpovily, skilky chasu neobkhidno dlia rozminuvannia Kyivskoi oblasti. (2023, June 13). [The Kyiv Regional Military Administration reported how long it will take to clear Kyiv Region]. Khroniky Obukhova. Retrieved from: ttps://obukhiv.info/news/v-kova-rozpovili-skilki-chasu-neobkhidno-dlya-rozminuvannya-kiivskoi-oblasti/ (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Russia destroys 12 Ukrainian hotels with nearly 1,000 rooms during invasion. (2023, January 23). NV. Retrieved from: https://english.nv.ua/nation/russia-destroys-12-ukrainian-hotels-with-nearly-1-000-rooms-during-invasion-50299352.html (accessed 1.07.2023).
Serhiivka na Odeshchyni. Rosiiany zavdaly raketnoho udaru, bahato zahyblykh ta poranenykh. (2022, July 1). [Serhiivka near Odessa. The Russians launched a rocket attack, many were killed and wounded.]. BBC News. Retrieved from: https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/news-61999992 (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Skilky chasu potrebuvatyme rozminuvannia Khersonshchyny, rozpovily v OVA. (2023, May 7). [How long will the demining of the Kherson region last, the Regional Military Administration said]. Rakurs. Retrieved from: https://racurs.ua/ua/n182770-skilky-chasu-potrebuvatyme-rozminuvannya-hersonschyny-rozpovily-v-ova.html (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Slyvka, R. (2021). Transformatsiia symvolichnykh landshaftiv Donbasu pid chas voiennoho konfliktu [Transformation of symbolic landscapes of Donbas during the military conflict], Mistse Ukrainy v yevropeiskomu prostori: heoprostorovi rysy ta yevropeiska unifikatsiia, 54-60 (in Ukrainian).
Stratehiia rehionalnoho rozvytku Zaporizkoi oblasti na period do 2027 roku. (2019). [Regional development strategy of the Zaporizhzhia region for the period until 2027]. Zaporizka oblasna derzhavna administratsiia. Retrieved from: https://www.zoda.gov.ua/news/45047/informatsiya-shodo-rozrobki-proektu-strategiji-2027-ta-planu-zahodiv-na-2021-2023-roki-z-jiji-realizatsiji.html (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Stratehiia rozvytku Bakhmutskoi miskoi obiednanoi terytorialnoi hromady na period do 2027 roku. (2020). [Development strategy of the Bakhmut city united territorial community for the period until 2027]. Bakhmutska miska rada. Retrieved from: ttp://misto-em.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/1-Strateg_ya-rozvytku-Bahmutska-OTG.pdf (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Stratehiia rozvytku Khersonskoi oblasti na period 2021 - 2027 rokiv. (2019). [Development strategy of the Kherson region for the period 2021 - 2027]. Khersonska oblasna derzhavna administratsiia. Retrieved from: https://khoda.gov.ua/image/catalog/files/%20%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%B2%D0%B8%D1%82%D0%BA%D1%83%20%D0%A5%D0%B5%D1%80%D1%81.%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%BB.%D0%BD%D0%B0%20%D0%BF%D0%B5%D1%80%D1%96%D0%BE%D0%B4%202021-2027%20%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BA%D1%96%D0%B2.pdf (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Stratehiia rozvytku m. Mariupolia do 2030 r. (2021). [Development strategy of the city of Mariupol until 2030.]. Retrieved from: https://era-ukraine.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Strategy_2030_Mariupol_compressed.pdf (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
«Suma zbytkiv velychezna i z bahatma nuliamy»: vlasnytsia hoteliu «Kramatorsk» rozpovila pro naslidky raketnoho udaru. (2022, September 20). [«The amount of damage is huge and with many zeros»: the owner of the «Kramatorsk» hotel spoke about the consequences of the missile strike]. Kramatorsk Post. Retrieved from: https://www.kramatorskpost.com/suma-zbitkiv-velicezna-i-z-bagatma-nulyami-vlasnicya-gotelyu-kramatorsk-rozpovila-pro-naslidki-raketnogo-udaru_84872 (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
U DSNS nazvaly naibilsh zaminovanu zvilnenu terytoriiu. (2022, December 2). [The State Emergency Service of Ukraine named the most mined liberated territory]. Slovo i dilo. Retrieved from: https://www.slovoidilo.ua/2022/12/02/novyna/suspilstvo/dsns-nazvaly-najbilsh-zaminovanu-zvilnenu-terytoriyu (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
UNWTO, O. S. (2022). Impact of the Russian offensive in Ukraine on international tourism. Retrieved from: https://www.unwto.org/impact-russian-offensive-in-ukraine-on-tourism (accessed 1.07.2023).
Vnaslidok obstrilu Khersona zahynuv prorosiiskyi eksdeputat VR – ZMI RF. (2022, September 25). [As a result of the shelling of Kherson, a pro-Russian ex-deputy of the Verkhovna Rada was killed - mass media of the Russian Federation.]. Radio Svoboda. Retrieved from: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/news-zhuravko-zagybel-kherson/32051123.html (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Vstup.OSVITA.UA. Retrieved from: https://vstup.osvita.ua/ (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Yankovskyi, O., Badiuk, O. (2023, April 07). «Pohrabovani abo zaseleni viiskovymy». Shcho vidbuvaietsia na okupovanykh kurortakh pivdnia? [«Robbered or occupied by the military». What is happening in the occupied resorts of the south?]. Radio Svoboda. Retrieved from: ttps://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/novyny-pryazovya-okupovani-kurorty-turystychnyy-sezon-2023/32351014.html (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Yoshida, K., Bui, H. T., & Lee, T. J. (2016). Does tourism illuminate the darkness of Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Journal of Destination Marketing & Management, 5(4), 333-340. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdmm.2016.06.003
Zabozhko, T. (2023, June 22). Palalo ponad hodynu: na bazi okupantiv pid Berdianskom stavsia vybukh. [It burned for more than an hour: an explosion occurred at the occupiers' base near Berdyansk]. Fakty. Retrieved from: https://fakty.com.ua/ua/proisshestvija/20230622-palalo-ponad-godynu-na-bazi-okupantiv-pid-berdyanskom-stavsya-vybuh/ (accessed 1.07.2023) (in Ukrainian).
Zafiksovani voienni zlochyny [Recorded war crimes]. Retrieved from: https://mkip.notion.site/mkip/7be52d2803994651a23a220a8ed85f1c?v=6ea517f19a8944f9a902a50156656eea (accessed 29.06.2023).
Zatserkovnyi V., Savkov P., Pampukha I., Vasetska К. (2020) Zastosuvannia tekhnolohii HIS ta DZZ v zadachakh monitorynhu lisovykh pozhezh [Application of GIS and remote sensing of the Earth for the forest fire monitoring] Visnyk Kyivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni T. Shevchenka.Viiskovo-spetsialni nauky, № 2(44), 54-57. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2217.2020.44.54-58 (in Ukrainian).
Zavarika, G. M. (2022). Military tourism as a peculiarity of tourism development in a post-conflict territory. Journal of Geology, Geography and Geoecology, 31(1), 186-193. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.15421/112218
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Studies of the Industrial Geography Commission of the Polish Geographical Society
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Articles are published under the terms of the Creative Commons License (CC BY-ND 4.0; Attribution– NoDerivs).